Talvar: Shocking similarities between Arushi Talvar & Sheena Bora murder cases!

-

You must have read writeups on shocking similarities between Abraham Lincoln & J.F.Kennedy's assassinations. We have a similar story in India also, not related to murder of any politicians but of 2 young ladies in different parts of the country.Just viewed movie "Talwar" & the story made me compare Arushi Talwar's murder case with Mumbai's Sheena Bora murder case. I was following newsreports  of this case till few years back and "Talwar" helped me to get back on the chronology and do some supplementary reading on the case. Those crime reporters who have seen "Talwar" & covered Sheena Bora murder case may notice following parallels between the 2 cases :

1) The 1st investigative team was negligent:
In Arushi's case it was UP Police & in Sheena's case it was Raigadh Police. If both had done their basic work sincerely in the beginning both cases would have been detected much earlier.

2) Second investigative team did the solid investigation:
In Arushi's case it was CBI director Arun Kumar's team which got new facts & made fresh arrests and in Sheena's case it was Rakesh Maria's team which detected the case & made all the arrests.

3) The second investigation team was removed before filing of chargesheet:
In Arushi's case Arun Kumar's team was removed & case was given to another team of CBI.Similarly in Sheena's case firstly police commissioner Rakesh Maria was removed & later on the investigation was transferred from Mumbai Police to CBI. It means both the cases were handled by 3 different investigating teams.

4) Motive of murder is still not clear in both the cases.

5) In Arushi's case parents were accused of murder & in Sheena's case also one of the parent is accused of murder.

6) In both the cases drivers of the families were also named as accused.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

#Bombayphile Telgi Scam: Crime Reporting In Mumbai 20 Years Ago

-
Image
  In the last two decades, the landscape of crime reporting in Mumbai has undergone a dramatic transformation. Gone are the days when crime reporters chronicled a never-ending saga of violence, featuring shootouts resulting from gang wars and police encounters. In addition to this “routine coverage,” a crime reporters had to demonstrate their investigative prowess by unearthing stories that unveiled corruption and administrative negligence. These fearless exposés, which often made those in power uncomfortable and insecure, were a common sight in the media. Back then, there was no WhatsApp, and a reporter who filed a "table story" was met with disdain. Unfortunately, this style of crime reporting has become increasingly rare, and the blame cannot be solely laid at the feet of crime reporters. The decline of crime reporting in Mumbai is a topic for another discussion. Today, I'm delving into the Telgi scam, a shining example of investigative journalism from Mumbai. This sc
Read more

नागरिक बनो, भक्त नहीं!

-
कर्नाटक नतीजे आने के बाद कई लोग सोशल मीडिया पर मेरे पोस्ट को पढकर ये अनुमान लगा रहे हैं कि शायद मैं कांग्रेसी हूं। अनुमान गलत है। तो क्या मैं भाजपाई हूं ? क्या मैं भक्त हूं ? नहीं जी। फिर क्या मैं वामपंथी हूं ? बिलकुल नहीं। ...तो फिर मैं कैसा शख्स हूं जिसकी कोई विचारधारा ही नहीं है ? मेरी सोच ऐसे लोगों के मन में उठ रहे तमाम सवालों से अलग है। मेरा परिचय भारत के एक नागरिक का है। मेरी नजर में जैसे ही आप किसी राजनीतिक पार्टी के फुलटाईम समर्थक / कार्यकर्ता बनते हैं या फिर किसी राजनेता के भक्त बन जाते हैं तो आप अपने आपको को उन अधिकारों से वंचित कर लेते हैं जो एक लोकतांत्रिक देश के नागरिक होने के नाते आपको मिले हैं। अगर आप किसी राजनेता के भक्त हैं तो आपको उसकी हर बात पर वाह वाह करनी पडेगी। आपको उसके हर उस फैसले का भी सार्वजनिक तौर पर समर्थन करना पडेगा जिसे निजी तौर पर आप गलत मानते होंगे। कई बार उसके फैसले ऐसे होते सकते हैं जो सीधे आपको और आपके घर वालों को प्रभावित करते हों, परेशान करते हों।...लेकिन आप तो भक्त ठहरे। आपको तो उसका भी समर्थन करना ही पडेगा। कई बार आप जिसके भक्त हैं उसके फैसले
Read more

#Bombayphile : The Cosmopolitanism of Mumbai And Its Aberrations

-
Image
    The residential tower where I live is a microcosm of Mumbai. My neighbours are Maharashtrian, Bengalis, Gujaratis, Tamilians, Keralities, Biharis and a few from other states of India. They practice different faiths like Hinduism, Islam, Sikhism, Jainism, Buddhism, Christianity and Zoroastrianism. The managing committee of the housing society comprises people of varied linguistic, religious, and regional origins. There is no rule barring a particular community from buying or renting property in the building. As long as you are paying your maintenance bills on time, you are treated with respect. There are hundreds of housing societies like mine where people belonging to different communities live harmoniously. However, recently an incident that happened in the suburb Mulund of Mumbai led to a tremendous uproar and questioned the city’s cosmopolitan image. It especially enraged a section of the Maharashtrian community. A Maharashtrian woman and her husband went to scout for an off
Read more